Four-Time Individual Independent Champions
| Wrestler | Team | Years |
|---|---|---|
| Mike Parker | St. Andrews | 1974-77 |
| John Brancaccio | St. Marks | 1975-78 |
| Greg Thomas | St. Marks | 1977-80 |
| John Fiss | Wilmington Friends/Salesianum | 1990-93 |
| Kyle Talley | St. Marks | 1994-97 |
| Bruce Kelly | St. Marks | 1995-98 |
| Andrew Donofrio | St. Marks | 1999-02 |
| Bobby Shaw | St. Marks | 1999-02 |
| Kyle Skinner | St. Marks | 2001-04 |
| Brian Willis | St. Marks | 2001-04 |
| Tom Abbott | St. Marks | 2004-07 |
| Jarrod Garnett | Caravel | 2005-08 |
| Matt Buckworth | Caravel/St. Marks | 2006-07, 2009-10 |
| Sean Dolan | St. Marks | 2007-10 |
| Josh Snook | St. Marks | 2008-11 |
| Justin Engelmann | St. Marks | 2012-15 |
| Zach Spence | Salesianum | 2016-19 |
| Luke Poore | Caravel | 2019-20, 2022-23 |
| Justin Griffith | Sanford | 2019-20, 2022-23 |
| Eddie Radecki | Caravel | 2022-25 |
| Luke Spoor | DMA/St. Marks | 2022-25 |
| Dominic Lucian | Tower Hill/Salesianum | 2023-26 |