Four-Time Individual Blue Hen Champions
| Wrestler | Team | Years |
|---|---|---|
| Kurt Howell | Newark | 1983-86 |
| Jeff Dellicompagni | William Penn | 1986-89 |
| Paul Antonio | William Penn | 1988-91 |
| Nick Dellicompagni | William Penn | 1990-93 |
| Mike Welch | Hodgson | 1998-01 |
| Jordan Sianni | Hodgson | 1999-02 |
| Brandon Bruce | Hodgson | 2004-07 |
| Colton McFatridge | Hodgson | 2005-08 |
| Nick Tiberi | Hodgson | 2005-08 |
| Chris Witte | Hodgson | 2007-10 |
| Dante Immediato | Middletown | 2014-17 |
| Brian Schneider | Middletown | 2016-19 |
| Williem Carl | Middletown | 2017-20 |
| Franklin Norris | William Penn | 2022-25 |
| Rusty Llyod | St. Georges | 2023-26 |