Three-Time Individual Blue Hen Champions
| Wrestler | Team | Years |
|---|---|---|
| Phil Askey | Brandywine | 1961-63 |
| Randy Marshall | Brandywine | 1961-63 |
| Floyd Thomas | De La Warr | 1964-66 |
| Bill Muckle | William Penn | 1965-67 |
| Craig Nau | Concord/Newark | 1966-68 |
| Nicky Episcopo | Dickinson | 1971-73 |
| Mike Anderson | Christiana | 1972-74 |
| Mark Lobley | Concord | 1976-78 |
| Dan Reeder | Christiana | 1978-80 |
| Coy Burke | William Penn | 1981-83 |
| Joe Archangelo | Claymont | 1987-89 |
| John Massey | William Penn | 1987-89 |
| Jim Zimmerman | William Penn | 1987-89 |
| Daryl Merganthaler | William Penn | 1992-94 |
| Pete Laucirica | Hodgson | 1995, 1997-98 |
| Aaron Jester | Hodgson | 1996-98 |
| Ryan Smith | Hodgson | 1998-00 |
| Derrick Davis | Hodgson | 1998-00 |
| James Fromal | William Penn | 1999-01 |
| Brian Welch | Hodgson | 2001-03 |
| Mike Grant | AI duPont | 2001, 2003-04 |
| Michael Albanese | St. Georges | 2011, 1013-14 |
| Brandon Hurd | St. Georges | 2013, 2015-16 |
| Nicholas Novarnik | St. Georges | 2016-18 |
| Daniel Sinclair | William Penn | 2020, 2022-23 |
| Louis Zitofsky | St. Georges | 2022-24 |
| Jeremiah Eastburn | Concord | 2023-25 |
| Eliedxander Jarquin-Torres | William Penn | 2023-25 |